How you would react if in my AU Tari would became more wrathful and prone to violence against her and friends enemies, even killing multiple villains?
Posted 5th Jun 2026r/SMG4
If SMG4 was written by Eric Kripke
Posted 25th May 2026r/SMG4
What if Luigi became more harsh and snarky towards Mario due constant bullying and abuse?
Posted 18th May 2026r/SMG4
Honestly Mario fully deserved that from Tari in "SMG4: The Day My Arm Went Psycho" (this is of course addressed to some SMG4 fans)
Posted 16th May 2026r/SMG4
Do you think Mr. Puzzles deserve live peacefully and happily in another universe?
What If Meggy got enough of Mr. Puzzles BS (spoilers for Invincible)
Posted 11th May 2026r/SMG4
What is your opinion about Tari unintentionally causing deaths of millions of people in Silica Coty in my AU due saving character and feeling remorseful?
Posted 9th May 2026r/SMG4
How Mr. Puzzles would react about Meggy being disowned by her parents after she were turned from inkling to human against her will during Anime Arc?
Posted 3rd May 2026r/SMG4
I swear that some of you guys are biased about Mario and have double standards
How do you think Mario would react if Tari crash out at him over Pokemon death animation pranks?
Posted 2nd May 2026r/SMG4
What is your thought on my take on Peach in my AU?
Posted 30th Apr 2026r/SMG4
What was a point of Meggy traumas and suffering, if they wasn't properly addressed and resolved?
Posted 29th Apr 2026r/SMG4
What If Mr. Puzzles instead of time traveling, decided to leave everyone he hurt alone and leave Mushroom Kingdom, living in town where nobody know him
Posted 28th Apr 2026r/SMG4
Double standards
Posted 12th Feb 2026r/SMG4
How you would react if SMG4 characters in my AU became more pragmatic in their methods and tactics?
Posted 9th Feb 2026r/SMG4
About Mr. Puzzles remorse
Posted 8th Feb 2026r/SMG4
Prove me wrong
Posted 3rd Feb 2026r/SMG4
How you would react if gentle characters (like Tari and Luigi) would grew spine and call out jerkish characters in my AU?
What is your opinion about my depiction of Beta-Tari in my AU?
Posted 1st Feb 2026r/SMG4
I find it on Depresso page on The Scrappy Wiki, how much do you agree with this point?
Posted 29th Jan 2026r/SMG4
[LOVED TROPE] media that are dark, but doesn't fall into "Too Bleak Stop Caring" territory and story is still optimistic and hopeful
Posted 10th Jan 2026r/TopCharacterTropes
In my opinion, Mr. Puzzles redemption is unearned
Posted 3rd Dec 2025r/SMG4
I find this on SMG4 WMG page on TV Tropes, how much do you think this is true?
Posted 8th Oct 2025r/SMG4
What Susie saw at last prophecy
Posted 3rd Aug 2025r/SMG4
How many Whimpu's it would need to defeat Melony?
Posted 2nd Aug 2025r/SMG4
What was your weirdest SMG4 related dream/nightmare?
Posted 29th May 2025r/SMG4
On which character you would make horror?
Posted 4th May 2025r/SMG4
What is the most disturbing/darkest/shocking SMG4 fanfic you ever read?
Posted 23rd Apr 2025r/SMG4
Showing 28 posts out of a possible 43.15 posts hidden as gallery mode enabled.
