The Critic

'The Critic' is an animated sitcom about New York film critic Jay Sherman. Created by former Simpsons writers Al Jean and Mike Reiss. The show aired for 23 episodes on ABC (1994) and Fox (1995).

Sort by: Hot, New, Top

Since when did Duke have progeny?!

Posted 5th Apr 2026u/PickleJuiceT

And remember, there’s no fish stick like Mrs. Pell’s..

Posted 18th Mar 2026u/PickleJuiceT

Jay contemplates eating a cactus

Posted 25th Feb 2026u/MacsMedia100

Posted 19th Feb 2026u/SanJoseThrowAway2023

The Critic Returns #5

Posted 2nd Feb 2026u/AndyDiplodocus

Repost: the Critic Returns #4

Posted 31st Jan 2026u/AndyDiplodocus

Repost: the Critic Returns #3

Posted 30th Jan 2026u/AndyDiplodocus

On Jeopardy yesterday

Posted 30th Jan 2026u/whackabumpty

Repost: The Critic Returns #2

Posted 29th Jan 2026u/AndyDiplodocus

Repost: the Critic Returns #1

Posted 29th Jan 2026u/AndyDiplodocus

The name's Monroe. James Monroe. And here's a taste of the Monroe Doctrine.

Posted 2nd Dec 2025u/FalseDmitriy

The Critic "Penguins Can't Fly"

Posted 11th Nov 2025u/Harold_Grundelson

Buy my DVD! Buy my DVD! Buy my DVD!

Posted 9th Nov 2025u/sheilamlin

Full of country goodness and green pea-ness!

Posted 4th Nov 2025u/CornTreeRoad

I apologize. It’s my…big hands. Is there anything else you desire?

Posted 23rd Oct 2025u/sheilamlin

AI Jay Sherman reviews Dragonball Evolution (2009)

Posted 25th Sep 2025u/JackFisherBooks

I present to you

Posted 28th Aug 2025u/Deep-Ad4351

Posted 12th Jul 2025u/sheilamlin

Bobby Sherman?!

Posted 15th Jun 2025u/chrisH82

Their cartoon hero, Winey Jacques

Posted 27th May 2025u/FalseDmitriy

My shirt for special occasions

Posted 26th May 2025u/sheilamlin

The Critic(s) (RLM/the Critic fanart)

Posted 22nd May 2025u/AndyDiplodocus

The Critic Returns #4

Posted 20th May 2025u/AndyDiplodocus

Sketches/doodles for the Critic comics

Posted 20th May 2025u/AndyDiplodocus

THE CRITIC - Main Theme By Hans Zimmer | ABC

Posted 20th May 2025u/Barbourwhat

Patches.... NOOOO!!!!!

Posted 20th May 2025u/BananaFriendOrFoe

since the sub is back and people liked my other drawing, some more art!

Posted 19th May 2025u/swirlinglaughter

Posted 19th May 2025u/Matthias_Doe

The Critic Returns #3

Posted 19th May 2025u/AndyDiplodocus

Posted 19th May 2025u/KnifeFightAcademy

This show was years ahead of its time

Posted 19th May 2025u/FalseDmitriy

The Critic Returns #2

Posted 18th May 2025u/AndyDiplodocus

We’re the bears who sing for Duke. Doo Dah, Doo Dah.

Posted 18th May 2025u/Matthias_Doe

The Critic Returns #1[OC]

Posted 17th May 2025u/AndyDiplodocus

Late 90s Simpsons borrowing jokes and plots from The Critic

Posted 17th May 2025u/chrisH82

Oh, what luck! There's a French fry stuck in my beard.

Posted 17th May 2025u/FalseDmitriy

Anyone else just get let in?

Posted 17th May 2025u/KnifeFightAcademy

This meme template I made stinks!

Posted 17th May 2025u/sheilamlin

Margo Sherman appreciation post!

Posted 4th Aug 2023Deleted user

We always say The Simpsons predict the future, but here's one for The Critic.

Posted 29th Jul 2023Deleted user

Showing 40 posts out of a possible 50.
10 posts hidden as gallery mode enabled.